Finn
CLF Steel · Cyclical · Industrial · Debt reduction · Thesis updated October 25, 2026

Contract resets and volume mandates project billion dollar earnings lift

01 Running thesis

The fix is showing up

Cleveland-Cliffs expects major financial gains heading into 2027. The company is seeing the benefits of exiting unprofitable legacy slab contracts and shifting its commercial models. Management doubled their expectation for the 2027 EBITDA uplift from contract resets, now projecting over $1 billion.

The bull case relies on structural EBITDA expansion. The company is actively shifting to take-or-pay volume minimums to enforce reliability with its auto customers. Furthermore, delaying the Burns Harbor C-furnace reline to 2028 preserves 500,000 tons of production during a highly profitable market window, paving a clear path to breaching the sub-2.5x leverage target by mid-2027.

The bear case centers on execution and trade risks. While the Canadian government tariff-rate quotas successfully restored profitability to Stelco hot-rolled operations, the galvanized lines remain unprofitable due to import dumping. Strategic catalysts like the POSCO partnership appear to be losing momentum, removing a potential upside lever.

Finn scoring remains cautious on valuation and financial health. The company is generating free cash flow to pay down its heavy debt load, but the successful execution of Q4 asset sales and auto contract renewals without friction will be critical.

Oct 2026▲Q3 2026 results strengthened the thesis for 2027. Management doubled their EBITDA uplift expectation to over $1 billion due to contract resets and shifted to take-or-pay volume minimums.
Jul 2026▲Q2 2026 results showed a return to positive free cash flow and a tripling of sequential EBITDA. Management highlighted an initial $500 million EBITDA catalyst for 2027 from resetting fixed contracts.
Apr 2026▲The Q1 2026 10-Q confirmed a $290 million revenue increase and a $310 million gross margin improvement year over year. It also gave a better outlook for Stelco as Canadian import levels fell after tariff-rate quotas.
Apr 2026▲The Q1 2026 call showed stronger adjusted EBITDA after the Calvert contract roll-off, but also flagged an $80 million energy cost hit. Management had completed $70 million of its $425 million 2026 asset-sale target.
Feb 2026▲The 2025 10-K confirmed that the unprofitable Calvert slab contract expired in December 2025 and was not renewed. This turned a major 2025 headwind into a 2026 earnings tailwind.
Oct 2025▲CLF disclosed asset-sale processes led by J.P. Morgan and a memorandum of understanding with a major global steel producer. These added clearer catalysts for deleveraging and possible strategic value.
Jul 2025→The Q2 2025 10-Q did not materially change the thesis. The key issues remained weak automotive demand, facility idlings, and the coming Calvert contract expiration.
May 2025▼Q1 2025 results were weak. CLF idled six operations, exited several unprofitable markets, and made the Calvert contract expiration the main recovery catalyst.
02 Business model

Ore to auto steel

CLF is vertically integrated. That means it mines iron ore, turns it into steel, and sells finished products. This integration provides a structural cost advantage because the company controls more of the steps that competitors may need to buy from others.

The company makes money primarily from flat-rolled steel used by automakers, factories, service centers, and infrastructure customers. Direct automotive sales make up a significant chunk of Steelmaking segment revenue, and the company is a leading supplier of automotive-grade steel in the U.S.

Pricing models are shifting. Management is transitioning the commercial structure so that minimum contracted tonnages are explicitly take-or-pay, increasing volume reliability. Concurrently, the company is transitioning non-auto fixed-price contracts toward index-linked pricing with lower discounts to capture spot market upside.

Where it breaks is clear. If auto demand falters, pushing take-or-pay terms onto OEMs during upcoming multi-year contract renewals may cause friction or volume loss. If hot-rolled coil prices fall or imports rise, CLF can lose margin quickly.

03 Product portfolio

Steel products that matter

Cash cow

Automotive flat-rolled steel

This is the core business and a major reason fixed annual contracts matter. The company is a leading U.S. supplier of automotive-grade steel.

Steady

Advanced high-strength steel

These grades help automakers make lighter and stronger vehicles. They support the competitive position with large auto customers.

Steady

Coated and cold-rolled products

Products such as hot-dipped galvanized, aluminized, and cold-rolled coil are used in autos, manufacturing, and construction-related markets.

Option

Electrical steels

Specialized electrical steels give exposure to higher-value uses. The company remains highly selective in this capital-intensive market.

Steady

Plate

CLF is shrinking parts of this business. In early 2026, it idled the smaller plate mill at Burns Harbor and the Gary plate finishing line.

Steady

Downstream parts and tubing

The company also sells stamped components, tooling, and tubing. These products extend beyond basic sheet steel.

04 Business segments

Mostly one segment

Steelmaking97%modest
Other and eliminations3%flat

For early 2026, CLF was mainly a Steelmaking company. Steelmaking revenue represented nearly all consolidated revenue, so the non-Steelmaking share remained small.

05 Risk factors

What could break the case

Contract renewal friction

High impact · Medium odds

Management expects over $1 billion in EBITDA improvement in 2027 by resetting contracts and enforcing take-or-pay minimums. If auto demand falters, pushing these terms onto OEMs during renewals could cause volume loss.

We watchQuarterly updates on multi-year contract renewals and auto OEM volume commitments.

Canadian operations falter

High impact · Medium odds

The Canadian market remains fragile. Although hot-rolled steel is profitable again, dumped imports continue to flood the Canadian galvanized steel market, preventing Stelco from realizing its full margin potential.

We watchCanadian government policy announcements regarding steel trade and Stelco segment margins.

Asset sales and POSCO deal stall

Medium impact · High odds

Management wants to reduce net debt below $2.5 billion by mid-2027. This relies heavily on imminent Q4 asset sales. Furthermore, the POSCO strategic partnership appears to be losing momentum.

We watchAnnouncements of completed asset sales or a definitive update on the POSCO partnership.

Steel prices roll over

High impact · Medium odds

A large part of sales is exposed to monthly index or spot pricing. If hot-rolled coil prices fall, the benefits of cost cuts and contract resets could be offset by lower realized prices on spot volumes.

We watchMonthly U.S. hot-rolled coil prices and CLF realized steel price per ton.
06 Quick answers

In one breath

What does Cleveland-Cliffs do?

Cleveland-Cliffs mines iron ore and makes steel in North America. Its main products are flat-rolled steel used by automakers, manufacturers, distributors, and infrastructure customers.

Why is the outlook improving for 2027?

Management expects to reset non-auto contracts to higher market prices and enforce take-or-pay minimums on auto volumes. They project this will add over $1 billion in EBITDA year over year.

Why is debt such a big issue for CLF?

Steel is cyclical, so high debt can become a problem when prices or demand weaken. Management says debt reduction is a priority and relies on free cash flow and imminent Q4 asset sales to reach their targets.

What should investors watch next?

Watch the auto OEM multi-year contract renegotiations testing the new take-or-pay structure. Also monitor Canadian trade policies and any finalization of Q4 asset sales.

07 Research standards

Sources and research notes

This page combines Finn's company research with public filings and other cited materials. The thesis is reviewed when material company information changes; Finn Scores use the latest available scoring data.

Thesis reviewed
October 25, 2026
Score data
November 15, 2026
Reviewed by
Shivam Bharuka
  1. Cleveland-Cliffs Q3 2026 Earnings Transcript
  2. Cleveland-Cliffs Q2 2026 Form 10-Q
  3. Cleveland-Cliffs Q1 2026 Form 10-Q
  4. Cleveland-Cliffs 2025 Form 10-K
08 Explore the industry

Comparable Steel companies

Companies near Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. in Finn's Steel industry ranking.

Get started with Finn today