Finn
NI Utilities · Regulated utility · Data centers · Natural gas · Thesis updated November 1, 2026

Microsoft joins GenCo as a $40 billion buildout begins

01 Running thesis

Big load, bigger test

NiSource has transformed from a steady utility into a utility with a massive data center buildout attached. The core business still earns money the normal utility way. It invests in pipes, wires, and power plants, then asks regulators to let it recover those costs plus a fair return.

The bull case centers on NIPSCO GenCo. The company added Microsoft as its third hyperscaler customer, bringing contracted capacity to nearly 4 GW. This momentum supports a new seven-year, $40 billion capital plan and an upgraded 10% to 11% earnings growth target through 2033. If these projects succeed, NiSource will compound growth well above the utility sector average while lowering retail customer bills by an estimated $1.75 billion.

The bear case focuses on execution and scale. The $40 billion capital plan introduces immense supply chain and financing risks over the next seven years. Regulatory friction also exists. A severe August derecho in Indiana could force unbudgeted storm hardening investments, and regulators recently rejected a $741 million gas tracker plan. Meanwhile, persistent power market constraints forced a fourth federal order delaying the retirement of a key coal plant.

This is why the story is attractive but complex. Growth has improved, yet the price already asks investors to believe in years of perfect execution. Finn's weaker valuation and financial health scores reflect the debt and price risks tied to this massive plan.

Oct 2026▲NiSource added Microsoft as its third hyperscaler customer and rolled out a seven-year, $40 billion capital plan. Management also raised long-term EPS growth guidance to 10% to 11%.
Aug 2026▲NiSource obtained IURC approval for both the original Amazon contract and the Alphabet contract, validating the GenCo model. However, a third federal order delayed the Schahfer coal plant retirement, and regulators rejected a $741 million gas TDSIC plan.
May 2026▲NiSource raised the scale of the data center story by adding Alphabet and expanding Amazon ADS to 2,800 MW by the end of 2032. The same update also raised concern because existing data center contracts now require $9.25 billion to $9.75 billion of assets.
Feb 2026→NiSource beat 2025 EPS guidance and ended the year with FFO to debt of 16.1%. That helped the financing story, but the data center capital need was still the key open question.
Oct 2025▲The first large data center contract turned the GenCo idea into a signed project. Management also introduced an 8% to 9% adjusted EPS CAGR target through 2033.
Aug 2025→Management said data center talks were still on track and clarified that the GenCo regulatory process was separate from signing a customer deal. That reduced timing risk but did not yet add a signed contract.
May 2025→The base utility plan remained intact, and management said data center capital would be incremental to the existing plan. Settlement talks on the GenCo filing were still underway.
Feb 2025▲The initial thesis was a regulated utility with 6% to 8% annual adjusted EPS growth from a $19.4 billion base capital plan. The main upside was unplanned data center demand in Northern Indiana.
02 Business model

Rates pay the base, contracts fuel growth

NiSource makes most of its money from regulated gas and electric utilities. It spends money on safe and reliable energy systems, then regulators decide how much customers should pay so the company can earn a set return.

Columbia Operations is the gas utility group outside Indiana. It serves customers in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Virginia, Kentucky, and Maryland. Growth here comes from replacing older pipes and getting those safety investments included in rates.

NIPSCO Operations serves Northern Indiana with gas and electric service. This is where the data center plan lives. GenCo supports large-load customers through special contracts with fixed capacity payments. These are payments for having power available, not only for power used. This structure shields existing retail customers from costs and is projected to generate $1.75 billion in savings for them.

The model can break if costs rise faster than regulators or customers allow. It can also break if NiSource needs too much debt to fund GenCo, or if severe weather events like the recent derecho force expensive grid repairs outside the base capital plan.

03 Product portfolio

What NiSource sells

Cash cow

Columbia Gas distribution

This is the multi-state gas utility group. It is slower growth, but it provides a steady base through regulated pipe replacement and safety spending.

Steady

NIPSCO electric utility

NIPSCO supplies electricity in Northern Indiana. It is the center of the company's coal-to-gas, renewable, and storage transition.

Steady

NIPSCO gas utility

This business distributes natural gas in Northern Indiana. It grows through customer additions, system upgrades, and approved rate recovery.

Growth engine

NIPSCO GenCo

GenCo is the new large-load platform serving data centers. It has signed contracts with Amazon, Alphabet, and Microsoft.

Option

Renewables and battery storage

NiSource is adding wind, solar, and batteries as it moves away from coal. Battery projects also support data center service under the pooled resource model.

Option

Large industrial infrastructure

NiSource can provide power and gas infrastructure to large customers. The opportunity is meaningful, but new deals require heavy generation assets and financing.

04 Business segments

Two reportable pieces

Columbia Operations56%modest
NIPSCO Operations44%growing fast

Mix is based on Q1 2026 reportable-segment operating revenue before Corporate and Other. GenCo will become a separate standalone segment by year-end.

05 Risk factors

What could go wrong

GenCo and base capital execution

High impact · Medium odds

NiSource plans to spend $40 billion over seven years, including $8 billion for GenCo. This enormous capital plan introduces major supply chain, execution, and financing risks. Cost overruns or delays could lower returns.

We watchWatch updates to the $40 billion capital plan, in-service dates for generation assets, and any new equipment delays.

Balance sheet pressure

High impact · Medium odds

The company must finance heavy front-loaded GenCo construction while preserving its 14% to 16% FFO to debt metrics. Issuing too much debt or equity could weaken the upgraded 10% to 11% per-share growth target.

We watchWatch FFO to debt ratios, equity issuance, and credit rating outlooks.

August derecho and storm hardening

Medium impact · High odds

A severe derecho hit Northern Indiana in August, prompting internal and regulatory reviews of the storm response. Regulators may demand significant new resiliency investments outside the base plan.

We watchWatch IURC orders on storm response and any new unbudgeted resiliency capital requirements.

MISO reliability keeps coal alive

Medium impact · High odds

NIPSCO planned to retire the R.M. Schahfer coal facility, but a fourth federal emergency order required it to stay online due to grid constraints. The company must now evaluate extending its life in the upcoming resource plan.

We watchWatch DOE orders, FERC cost recovery filings, and the new Integrated Resource Plan for Schahfer retirement dates.

Gas modernization regulatory pushback

Medium impact · Medium odds

The IURC previously rejected NIPSCO's $741 million multi-year gas tracker plan. Regulators want better proof of the benefits for gas investments, which could stall the recovery of base capital.

We watchWatch IURC orders on gas trackers and rate case settlements in Indiana.
06 Quick answers

In one breath

What does NiSource do?

NiSource owns regulated gas and electric utilities. Its main brands are Columbia Gas across several states and NIPSCO in Northern Indiana.

Why do investors care about NiSource data centers?

Data centers need huge amounts of power. NiSource's NIPSCO GenCo has contracts with Amazon, Alphabet, and Microsoft, which could drive faster earnings growth than a normal utility plan.

What is the biggest risk for NI stock?

The biggest risk is execution on the $40 billion capital plan. The company must finance and build massive assets for data centers and base utility upgrades while keeping regulators and credit agencies comfortable.

Is NiSource only an electric utility?

No. It has both gas and electric operations. Columbia Operations is gas distribution, while NIPSCO includes both gas and electric service in Northern Indiana.

07 Research standards

Sources and research notes

This page combines Finn's company research with public filings and other cited materials. The thesis is reviewed when material company information changes; Finn Scores use the latest available scoring data.

Thesis reviewed
November 1, 2026
Score data
November 15, 2026
Reviewed by
Shivam Bharuka
  1. NiSource Q1 2026 Form 10-Q
  2. NiSource Q2 2026 Earnings Transcript
  3. NiSource Q3 2026 Earnings Transcript
08 Explore the industry

Comparable Utilities - Regulated Gas companies

Companies near NiSource Inc in Finn's Utilities - Regulated Gas industry ranking.

Get started with Finn today