Record efficiency offsets slowing loan growth in competitive markets
- Q3 2026 delivered record earnings per share and a record-low 44.9% efficiency ratio.
- Total deposits grew 11% annualized, driven by $1 billion in organic business account growth.
- Loan growth slowed to 3% annualized due to disciplined pricing in a highly competitive market.
- Management tempered full-year loan growth expectations to the lower end of its 6% to 8% range.
- The bank hired 26 new relationship managers to drive future commercial and wealth growth.
A highly efficient bank managing slower loan demand
Old National is proving it can run a highly efficient bank even as lending slows. In the third quarter of 2026, the company posted a record-low 44.9% efficiency ratio alongside 11% annualized deposit growth. However, a competitive market and disciplined loan pricing slowed total loan growth to 3% annualized, down from the 8.3% pace seen earlier in the year.
The bull case rests on massive deposit generation and strict expense control. With $1 billion in organic business account growth recently, the bank has the funding it needs. Management expects modest margin expansion in the fourth quarter as earning assets reprice. Old National also invested heavily in future growth by hiring 26 new commercial and wealth relationship managers.
The bear case centers on the top line. Because loan growth slowed, management now expects full-year loan and net interest income growth to land at the lower end of previous targets. Elevated deposit rates reflect intense competition for cash. If mortgage fees remain soft and deposit costs stay high, it will be harder to grow earnings. Finn scores the bank at a 2.9 overall, reflecting solid operational performance offset by average marks for financial health and sentiment.
Classic banking, spread-driven profits
Old National makes most of its money the classic bank way. It gathers deposits from households and businesses, lends that money out, and keeps the spread. That spread shows up in net interest income, which is the core driver of the bank's profits.
The simple model works best when deposits are stable, borrowers are healthy, and loan rates stay above funding costs. It can struggle when the bank must pay more for deposits, when borrowers miss payments, or when the economy in its markets slows down.
Fees add a second income stream. Noninterest income includes wealth and investment services fees, deposit service charges, and capital markets revenue. Management is working to grow these fee businesses to build a more balanced earnings engine that does not rely entirely on net interest income.
Loans first, fees second
Commercial loans
Commercial loans are a key growth driver, supported by strong commercial and industrial lending.
Commercial real estate loans
Commercial real estate represents a major portion of the loan book. It is a large earnings source but carries cycle risk if property values fall.
Residential real estate loans
Residential real estate loans give the bank exposure to local housing markets across its footprint.
Consumer loans
Consumer loans are smaller than the commercial books and provide diversification.
Deposits
Core deposits are the critical low-cost input that lets the bank fund loan growth while protecting margins.
Wealth and capital markets fees
Fee income gives Old National alternative ways to earn. Management is focused on growing this segment to diversify revenue.
Loan book mix
Old National does not present separate operating segments in its SEC filings. The mix below uses loan categories disclosed during 2026, showing where credit exposure sits.
What could break the story
Deposit cost squeeze
High impact · Medium oddsOld National needs low-cost deposits to fund loan growth at good spreads. While deposit growth was strong in the third quarter, the market remains highly competitive. If customers demand higher rates or move money elsewhere, margins will suffer.
Commercial credit turns
High impact · Medium oddsThe bank has a large commercial and commercial real estate loan book. That is where growth has historically been strongest, but it is also where a slower economy can show up quickly. Credit metrics have been improving, but the portfolio requires constant monitoring.
Economic slowdown chills loan demand
Medium impact · Medium oddsLoan growth slowed to 3% annualized in the third quarter, causing management to temper its full-year guidance to the lower end of the 6% to 8% range. If business confidence falls further, borrowers may delay projects and draw fewer loans, breaking the main growth story.
Bremer stock overhang
Medium impact · Low oddsThe Bremer Trust stock position remains a technical overhang because a large holder can affect trading if it sells. Old National has a right of first refusal, but any surprise block sale could pressure the stock.
Capital rules tighten
Medium impact · Low oddsBanks must hold enough capital against risk-weighted assets. Changes to Basel III rules could alter how much capital Old National needs, which affects how much cash it can use for share buybacks and dividends.
In one breath
What does Old National Bancorp do?
Old National Bancorp is a regional bank based in Indiana with operations in the Midwest and Southeast. It takes deposits, makes commercial and consumer loans, and earns money from the interest spread and banking fees.
Why did ONB's stock thesis change in late 2026?
Loan growth slowed to 3% annualized in the third quarter, but the bank offset this with a record-low efficiency ratio and 11% annualized deposit growth. Management also added 26 new commercial and wealth relationship managers to drive future revenue.
What is the biggest risk for ONB stock?
The key risk is funding costs. If deposit costs rise faster than loan yields, or if customers shift cash to higher-yielding accounts, net interest margin will shrink and limit earnings growth.
Is Old National mainly a commercial real estate bank?
Commercial real estate is its largest loan category, but the bank is broader than that. It has a fast-growing commercial and industrial loan book, plus residential and consumer lending segments.
Sources and research notes
This page combines Finn's company research with public filings and other cited materials. The thesis is reviewed when material company information changes; Finn Scores use the latest available scoring data.
- Thesis reviewed
- October 25, 2026
- Score data
- November 15, 2026
- Reviewed by
- Shivam Bharuka
Comparable Banks - Regional companies
Companies near Old National Bancorp in Finn's Banks - Regional industry ranking.

