Finn
AXP Payments · Large cap · Financials · Premium cards · Thesis updated October 25, 2026

Accelerating card fees and cost cuts drive raised earnings outlook

01 Running thesis

Premium wins, funding new investments

American Express is proving that rich benefits can support high fees. In the third quarter of 2026, net card fee growth accelerated to 17 percent. The company is using this momentum to fund future growth and improve efficiency. Management raised full-year earnings guidance, aided by an investment gain that funded a $336 million restructuring charge to cut 5 percent of the global workforce.

The best part of the story remains the premium consumer base. U.S. Consumer spending grew 9.4 percent in the third quarter, while International Card Services spending grew 11 percent. High card member retention and new deals, like an exclusive partnership to integrate Airbnb listings, continue to validate the core strategy.

The bear case is not gone. Commercial Services spending grew just 3 percent in the third quarter. While management announced a product refresh roadmap earlier in the year, intense competition and the exit of small business co-brand portfolios continue to weigh on the segment.

The other major watch item is regulation. The company recently paid a civil money penalty to the OCC. Furthermore, American Express anticipates becoming a Category II bank holding company in 2026 because cross-border activity crossed the $75 billion threshold. Category II status means tougher capital and liquidity rules. That could matter for dividends, buybacks, and the price investors are willing to pay for the stock.

Oct 2026▲Q3 2026 results highlighted accelerating 17 percent card fee growth and an exclusive Airbnb partnership. The company also announced a 5 percent workforce reduction.
Jul 2026▲Q2 2026 results showed strong consumer momentum. Management raised revenue guidance to 10 percent and announced the proposed acquisition of TheFork.
Apr 2026▲Q1 2026 results strengthened the premium card thesis. Revenue grew 11 percent, EPS rose 18 percent, and net card fees grew 18 percent.
Apr 2026▼The same Q1 filing raised the urgency of the regulatory risk. American Express now expects to become a Category II firm in Q2 2026.
Apr 2026→Management gave more detail on the Commercial Services fix, including 8 new or improved products and capabilities in 2026.
Feb 2026▲The 2025 10-K supported the bull case with strong full-year performance and a planned dividend increase.
Jan 2026▲Q4 2025 guidance pointed to 9 to 10 percent revenue growth in 2026 and stable credit metrics.
Oct 2025▲Q3 2025 showed faster billed business growth and early demand for the refreshed U.S. Platinum cards.
02 Business model

A closed loop with fees

American Express runs a closed-loop payments network. That means it issues cards to customers, signs up merchants, and runs the network that moves the payment. Visa and Mastercard mostly run networks. American Express takes more of the customer and merchant relationship itself.

The company earns money in three main ways. It collects discount revenue from merchants when a customer uses an Amex card. It earns net interest income when customers carry balances. It also collects net card fees, which are annual fees paid by cardholders.

The model works best when customers spend heavily, pay their bills, and keep paying annual fees. That is why American Express focuses on premium consumers and businesses. These customers tend to spend more and usually have better credit quality.

The model can struggle if rewards and lounge benefits cost too much, if merchants push back on fees, or if credit losses rise. A slow commercial business also limits the whole company, as business cards and expense tools are a major growth target.

03 Product portfolio

Cards, merchants, and membership

Growth engine

U.S. consumer cards

This is the core premium engine. The U.S. Platinum portfolio is driving spending, fees, and engagement among high-income customers.

Option

Commercial cards and payments

Commercial is the main turnaround project. The segment is seeing slow growth but is introducing new products and features like the ChatGPT statement credit.

Growth engine

International card services

International is a fast-growing segment by billed business. Growth is helped by spending across countries and customer types outside the United States.

Cash cow

Merchant and network services

This segment runs the global payments network, signs merchants, and works with third-party issuers. It supports the closed-loop model.

Steady

Travel, dining, and lifestyle assets

Partnerships like the Airbnb integration, Resy, and lounges help make annual fees feel worth paying. They also raise the cost of keeping premium customers happy.

Option

Center expense management

Center adds software for business expense management. It is important because American Express wants to offer more than just cards to commercial clients.

04 Business segments

Where revenue comes from

U.S. Consumer Services48%growing fast
Commercial Services23%modest
International Card Services19%growing fast
Global Merchant and Network Services11%modest

Segment mix is based on early 2026 total revenues net of interest expense across the four reportable segments. Corporate and other items are not included in the mix.

05 Risk factors

What could go wrong

Category II capital rules

High impact · High odds

American Express expects to become a Category II firm in 2026. That status brings higher capital, liquidity, and prudential requirements. If the new rules require more capital to be held inside the company, buybacks could be lower than investors expect.

We watchManagement comments on the CET1 target range, stress capital buffer, and buyback pace.

Execution risk on restructuring

Medium impact · Medium odds

The company is executing a global restructuring to eliminate approximately 5 percent of its workforce. Cost cuts can improve margins, but they introduce near-term execution risk if customer service or product development slows.

We watchOperating margins and management updates on the $336 million restructuring plan.

Commercial turnaround stalls

Medium impact · High odds

Commercial Services remains a weak spot, with spending up only 3 percent in the third quarter of 2026. Intense competition and the exit of small business co-brand portfolios could stall the recovery despite recent product launches.

We watchCommercial Services billed business growth and updates on the co-brand portfolio exits.

Merchant fee pressure

Medium impact · Medium odds

Discount revenue is the largest revenue line, making merchant economics critical. Laws, lawsuits, surcharging, steering, or lower competitor pricing can pressure the fee American Express keeps from each transaction.

We watchMerchant discount rate trends, surcharging rules, and updates on merchant litigation.

Premium benefits cost too much

Medium impact · Medium odds

Premium cards need rewards, lounges, dining, and travel perks to justify high fees. The company is actively investing profit upside into marketing and partnerships. If benefit costs rise faster than revenue, margins can suffer.

We watchGrowth in Card Member rewards and Card Member services compared with revenue growth.
06 Quick answers

In one breath

How does American Express make money?

It earns discount revenue when customers use cards at merchants, net interest income when customers carry balances, and net card fees from annual card fees. Its closed-loop network lets it control more of the payment process than rivals.

Why do investors care about net card fees?

Net card fees show whether customers are willing to pay for premium benefits. Strong growth in this area supports the idea that the company still has pricing power.

What is the main weakness at American Express?

Commercial Services has been the main weak spot. It consistently grows slower than the consumer and international segments, facing heavy competition in the corporate card market.

What does Category II mean for American Express?

Category II is a tougher U.S. bank regulatory category for large firms with major cross-border activity. It raises capital and liquidity demands, which could affect the company's ability to buy back stock.

07 Research standards

Sources and research notes

This page combines Finn's company research with public filings and other cited materials. The thesis is reviewed when material company information changes; Finn Scores use the latest available scoring data.

Thesis reviewed
October 25, 2026
Score data
November 15, 2026
Reviewed by
Shivam Bharuka
  1. American Express Q3 2026 earnings call transcript
  2. American Express Q2 2026 Form 10-Q
  3. American Express Q1 2026 Form 10-Q
08 Explore the industry

Comparable Credit Services companies

Companies near American Express Company in Finn's Credit Services industry ranking.

Get started with Finn today